screening_icon_2_blue

Screening and shortlisting

It is important to ensure that all candidates are assessed fairly and consistently. With some careful consideration and by applying clear, agreed-upon criteria, organisations can help reduce bias and consider a more diverse range of applicants.

People in a meeting room. A person using a powered wheelchair shakes hands with a man at the front of the room.

Set clear criteria

Prior to shortlisting, determine selection criteria and develop a shortlisting matrix to facilitate objective decisions on how to shortlist. Any people developing or using these tools should refresh their understanding of bias and assumptions.

Illustration of three people standing around an easel with a numbered list, appearing to discuss the items displayed.

Panel selection

For larger organisations, panels can help reduce the risk of only hiring people who are like us.

An effective panel member should be able to understand how to recognise and address bias, apply cultural competence, and be confident engaging with disabled candidates.

They also improve understanding and can help build rapport with candidates more quickly. To minimise bias and strengthen decision-making, include panel members in assessing and shortlisting, interviewing and the final selection stages.

Where possible, enhance your panel by:

  • Including people representing diverse genders, lived experiences of disability, rainbow identities and a range of cultural backgrounds.
  • Having at least one member who shares a relevant background with the candidate.
  • Limiting the number of panel members to remain manageable and to avoid overwhelming the candidate.
Two people sit at a table in an office setting, communicating using NZ Sign Language. On the left is a person with tā moko smiling warmly, and the person on the right is signing to them.

Don't assume

When screening for suitability, if you’re unsure how a candidate would perform the role, don’t assume they’re not capable of doing it.

Illustration of a person walking while holding a briefcase and balancing a glowing lightbulb on one finger.

Allow support people

Some disabled people might work with a professional to assist them with finding employment. Allow this person to engage with you during the shortlisting process to reduce chances of unconscious bias impacting decisions.

A man (support person) touches the shoulder of a younger man sitting down.

Personal disclosure

Job candidates and employees are not required by law to disclose personal information about a disability unless it could affect their ability to perform in the role. Creating a safe and supportive environment – one that clearly demonstrates a commitment to accessibility and inclusion – can encourage individuals to share relevant information.

Be mindful that many disabilities are not visible, and people may choose not to disclose these to a potential employer.

Young person wearing blue headphones working at computer workstation with multiple monitors. They are smiling at the camera.

Beware of AI

AI recruitment tools can unintentionally reinforce biases and disadvantage disabled candidates, and should be avoided until the technology significantly advances.

Automated screening software may filter out applicants with gaps in their employment history due to medical reasons, without considering the reason for those gaps. It’s important to critically evaluate the use of such tools and ensure that manual review processes are in place to counteract potential bias.

AI video assessment tools may fail to fairly evaluate individuals with facial differences, stutters, or neurodivergence, for example. This can lead to exclusion from consideration right from the beginning.

AI Bot coming out of laptop screen

Resources and Further Reading